If curators keep rejecting your song, it probably isn't because the song is bad. I know that's the first thing you think when "why are curators rejecting my song?" is on repeat. But rejection is the normal result: on SubmitHub the average approval rate across all genres is about 30% [3]. Most declines come down to a short list of fixable things, and the biggest one is fit.

There's also a newer reason. On 28 August 2026 Hypebot reported a SubmitHub study of over a million July 2026 releases, run with an AI Music Detector built to help curators filter submissions [1]. It found 38.5% contained AI audio, and 31% of artists whose tracks flagged positive said they used no AI tools at all [1]. So how you handle AI now matters when you pitch.

Why are curators rejecting my song?

A low approval rate usually comes down to one of these, not a bad song:

  • The song doesn't match the playlist.
  • You sent it to curators who almost never say yes.
  • The track isn't quite up to the standard of that niche yet.
  • The pitch made it hard for the curator to say yes.
  • You used AI somewhere and didn't say so.

Curators also say no for reasons you'll never see, and some won't reply at all. Focus on the parts you can control.

Reason 1: it doesn't fit the playlist

What playlist curators look for first is fit. A decline that only says it doesn't fit the vibe feels dismissive. It's usually true.

Jenny Morrison, a musician who has taught music business for over a decade, makes the point in a September 2026 curator's guide [2]: a playlist has a vibe and a flow. If your tempo, mood or type of lead singer doesn't match, it gets ignored. She sees songs with vocals pitched to instrumental-only playlists and often doesn't respond to them [2].

First, listen to the playlist's latest additions. Would your track sound odd between them? A good starting point is to pick three to five artists who sound like you and look for playlists that feature them [2]. On SubmitHub, read the curator's About section and preview the songs they've shared [3].

Reason 2: you picked the wrong curators

Some curators are just very picky. On SubmitHub, curators with very low approval rates are highly selective, while those around 30% or higher are more open to new music [3]. If your list is full of the first kind, the declines say more about the list than the song.

Our data: most playlists you can reach are small

Across the 23,716 Spotify playlists in the MusicMinutes database with a listed curator contact route, the median has 939 followers. A quarter have under 221, a quarter have over 4,113, and only 1 in 10 has more than 17,264. The median MusicMinutes quality score (0-100) is 44.

Source: MusicMinutes database of 23,716 Spotify playlists with a listed curator contact route (botted and payola playlists removed), follower counts and quality scores refreshed weekly; checked 3 Nov 2026.

So if you only aim at the biggest names, you skip most of the playlists in that box. Every playlist in that box is searchable by genre, mood or similar artist in Playlist Search, with its quality score and verified curator contacts. Mix in the small and mid-sized playlists where your sound fits. On SubmitHub, send in small batches (it suggests two to eight curators at a time) and adjust before the next batch [3]. And if a curator has said yes before, try them again with a similar song.

Reason 3: the track isn't competitive for that niche yet

I'll say this one gently. Sometimes a good song still sits a step below what that niche usually adds. The usual suspects are a mix that isn't quite at the genre's standard, a vocal that doesn't stand out, an arrangement that takes too long to get going, or a track that doesn't feel distinctive enough.

If several curators raise the same concern, try a different track from your catalogue. That beats pushing the same song harder.

Reason 4: the pitch made it hard to say yes

Curators are busy. Morrison says she has about two minutes per pitch, and that full-album pitches overwhelm her [2]. So send one song. Spotify works the same way for its own editors: "You can only pitch one song at a time", and more detail gives your song a better chance [5]. If you pitch Spotify's editors through Spotify for Artists, do it at least 7 days before release so they have time to listen [5].

Write in your own voice, because pitches that read as if ChatGPT wrote them feel impersonal [2]. A short, honest note about why the song suits that playlist beats a polished paragraph. For the full email process, read our guide on how to pitch your song to Spotify playlist curators.

Reason 5 (new in 2026): AI you didn't mention

Curators have a new filter. Hypebot's write-up of the SubmitHub study says self-reporting alone is no longer enough [1], and SubmitHub's Jason Grishkoff calls disclosure "the path forward" [1]. Morrison adds that many curators are put off by AI [2].

If any part is AI-generated, say which part in the pitch: the instrumental, the vocals or the whole song [2]. One plain line is enough. Some curators will still pass, but Morrison's point is that hiding it can damage the relationship [2], and that's harder to fix than a no.

If you used no AI at all, keep your stems and project files. Since 31% of flagged artists in that study said they used none [1], proof of how you made the song is worth having.

On Spotify itself, AI Credits launched in April 2026 to show listeners which parts of a record involved AI [4][6]. You can't fill them in inside Spotify. They arrive as metadata from your distributor, and at launch DistroKid was the only delivery partner passing those fields [4].

Spotify's editors won't program slop or spam, and Spotify says it has taken more than 50 million such tracks out of recommendations this year [6].

How to read declines without losing heart

Rejections sting. But a playlist submission rejected five times in a row is still telling you something, so treat each decline as data about your targeting or your track.

Note who you sent to and what they said, then look for patterns after each batch. Mostly fit? Change your targeting. Mix or vocal comments? Change the song. Change one or two things at a time, because if you change everything at once you never learn what worked. And when a curator says no, gives no reason or doesn't answer, accept it and move on [2].

If you want somewhere low-risk to send a track while you work this out, MusicMinutes has Submit. You pitch a song from your own Spotify catalogue to MusicMinutes' own playlists in one click, a real person checks the genre, style and quality fit, and you see the status and feedback in your dashboard. Three submissions a month are included in the subscription, and there are no bots.

SubmitHub is still good for fast feedback from lots of curators. It doesn't promise placements, though [3]. Even Spotify says pitching doesn't guarantee placement [5], so be wary of anyone who does.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal for most curators to say no?

Yes. On SubmitHub the average approval rate across genres is about 30% [3], so most pitches being declined is normal, even for good songs.

Should I resubmit a rejected song to the same curator?

I'd usually leave it. Send past supporters something similar, and if several curators flag the same problem, pitch a different track.

Do curators listen to the whole song?

Don't count on it. One curator says she has about two minutes per pitch [2], so get to the best part quickly and keep the message short.

Will using AI get my song rejected?

Not automatically. Many curators are put off by AI [2], so tell them up front which part used it. Spotify's editors say they don't program content identified as slop or spam [6], which isn't the same as honestly credited AI.

What if a curator never replies?

Some curators never reply, and that's an answer in itself [2]. For follow-up timing, see our pitching guide, then move on to the next curator.

References

Facts checked 3 November 2026 by Paul Nicholls against the sources below.